Source: raw/New_BEST_AI_image_generator_is_here.md. Creator: AI Search. URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9tpIc8PVKM. Duration: about 32 min. Platform: YouTube (auto-captions, fetched 2026-10-30; uploaded 2026-09-10). Sponsored by Higgsfield. Caption fixes: “GPZ / GBT image” → GPT Image, “Cance / Miniax” → Seedance / MiniMax, “topography” → typography (where he means type design).

AI Search ran about 24 hard prompts through GPT Image 2.5 (the high-quality Sunburst variant), GPT Image 2 and Google’s Nano Banana 2, after demonstrating 2.5’s new sketch input, annotation edits and transparent layers assembled into a PSD. His verdict: 2.5 is “slightly better” than GPT Image 2 in most cases, “not a huge significant leap,” and both GPT models beat Nano Banana 2 on nearly every test. The useful findings for production work are the layer and transparency tricks, and the categories where 2.5 is worse than 2 (dense grids, chart conversion, UI redesign). All judgments are his, from single generations.

Key Takeaways

  • Transparent layers are the practical new trick. 2.5 generated five sequential transparent layers (foreground to background) of a lake scene and assembled them into a PSD in about 4 minutes. It also decomposed an existing poster into separate transparent layers (background, person, each text element) in a PSD in about 6 minutes, so each element could be moved and resized.
  • Draw or annotate instead of describing. ChatGPT’s new Sketch tool (plus menu → Sketch) turned a crude drawing into a drone photo of an ocean-view house; writing edit instructions directly on a photo and asking 2.5 to follow the annotations also worked.
  • Multi-turn consistency is better: a cube rotated over 150 frames stayed consistent, which is what community stop-motion animations rely on.
  • Where 2.5 won (his calls): YouTube homepage mockup, weekly outfit infographic, sprite sheet (slightly), exploded device diagram, floor-plan view (least wrong), Where’s Waldo (least wrong), clock-and-wine-glass, a product held by an influencer with small text preserved (but a malformed hand).
  • Where GPT Image 2 won: a 100-poster anime grid (2.5’s faces were messed up), table-to-bar-chart conversion (2.5 misread one value), and a landing-page redesign (2.5 “decided to add way too much detail”).
  • Style difference: 2.5 “tends to add a lot more details” you did not ask for and looks more natural and amateur; GPT Image 2 is more literal and polished. 2.5 drops the yellowish tinge he still sees in GPT Image 2.
  • All three still fail Chinese/English street signage, a labelled biology worksheet, endemic Borneo frog species, a correct mate-in-two chess diagram, and a camera view from a specific door on a floor plan.
  • Pricing he reads from the API page: about 0.5¢ for a low-quality 1024×1024 image, 21¢ at max quality, and roughly 40¢ for a max-quality 4K 16:9 image ^[ambiguous] (the caption drops the unit). Flare and Sunburst cost the same; Flare has about 50% lower latency.

Results by test

TestWinner (his call)Note
Grid of 100 anime posters with namesGPT Image 2Nano Banana 2 had web search but produced gibberish posters
Messy Windows 11 desktop (Slack, Gmail, Excel, PowerPoint)Tie, GPT 2.5 and 2Both Excel sheets added up correctly; Nano Banana 2 worst
YouTube homepage for a tech broGPT 2.5Narrow margin
Brand identity board for an eco matcha brandTie, all threeLogo grid, mood board, palette, type, mock-ups all present
7-day women’s outfit infographicGPT 2.5GPT 2 close
5×5 sprite sheet, princess sprinting then slashingGPT 2.5 (slightly)Nano Banana 2’s grid could not be animated
Complex table to bar chartsGPT Image 22.5 misread one total-response-time value (the caption garbles the numbers); Nano Banana 2 mangled logos and legend
TikTok livestream screenshotTie, GPT models2.5 more casual, 2 more polished
Full typeface from a few sample wordsClose, GPT models2.5 changed the W; 2 added “hello world”
Exploded, labelled phone diagramGPT 2.5Accuracy not checked
Black-and-white manga fight page from two referencesNone good2.5 over-detailed; 2 more coherent but yellow
Landing-page redesign from a screenshotGPT Image 2
Ad storyboard from a product imageTie, GPT modelsFeed it to a video model afterwards
Hong Kong street with Chinese/English signsAll failGibberish text in all three
”Gameplay of GTA 6”GPT 2.5Added a logo and a wrong minimap
Biology worksheet labelled in student handwritingAll failAbout half wrong
3×3 endemic Borneo frogs with namesAll fail
World topography map with labels and statsClose, GPT modelsMissing African and Southeast Asian labels
Room photo from the main door of a floor planGPT 2.5 (least wrong)None took the right viewpoint
Chess mate-in-two diagramAll fail
A–Z animal alphabet posterGPT models2.5 adds unrequested extras
11:15 on a clock, wine glass full to the brimGPT 2.5Both GPT models correct
Where’s Waldo sceneGPT 2.5 (least wrong)He could not find Waldo in it
K-pop influencer holding a text-heavy productGPT 2.5, except a malformed handText preserved; GPT 2 got scale wrong

Variants, access and leaderboards

  • Flare: faster, about 50% lower latency, slightly lower quality. Sunburst: “built for premium workflows with tighter control,” slower. Same price.
  • Access (at recording): rolling out to ChatGPT, Work and Codex on all tiers including Free, with usage limits; also via the API. Up to 4K output.
  • Leaderboards he shows: #1 on the text-to-image arena, “just slightly above” GPT Image 2; 2.5 Sunburst #1 on image editing, “much higher” than GPT Image 2.

Try It

  1. Make editable ad assets: ask 2.5 to “break this poster down into separate transparent layers, then put all the layers together into a PSD file.” Re-layout the elements in Photoshop or Photopea instead of regenerating.
  2. Generate layered illustrations for parallax or motion graphics: request N sequential transparent layers from foreground to background, assembled into a PSD. ^[inferred] Layered PSDs drop straight into an animation tool.
  3. Annotate, don’t describe: draw arrows and notes on the image itself and prompt “use GPT Image 2.5 to edit the image based on the annotations and instructions in the image.”
  4. Keep GPT Image 2 for literal jobs (dense grids, chart conversions, UI redesigns) where 2.5’s extra detail gets in the way, and check every number in a generated chart.
  5. Budget by quality setting: draft at low quality (about half a cent), finish at max (about 21¢ at 1024²).

Open Questions

  • The 4K max-quality price is garbled in the caption (“roughly 40 widescreen 4K image”); confirm on OpenAI’s pricing page.
  • Single generations per model per prompt; no repeated trials or blind judging.
  • Which interface ran the PSD assembly (ChatGPT’s code tool or Codex) is not stated; ChatGPT presumably wrote the PSD file with code.